Edinburgh: Five Star Reviews
If you couldn't make it to Edinburgh this year, why not sit back and enjoy some of the top-rated shows from around the festivals courtesy of BBC Arts?
We've included performances available on BBC Arts that scored at least one five star review, with some reviews of three and four stars included for balance.
The List magazine's list of over 2000 Edinburgh shows ranked by review ratings

Exhibit B
Moving, vital, disturbing, unbearable, essential… just some of the words reviewers have used to describe Exhibit B, one of the most controversial works at 2014's Edinburgh International Festival.
South African artist Brett Bailey produced a unique hybrid of performance and exhibition looking at themes of racism and Europe's colonial history via a set of 13 fixed installations.
-
Explore Exhibit B
Artist Brett Bailey provides insight into the staging of the often disturbing scenes in the work, plus seven films of the exhibits, cast interviews and photographs.

What the reviewers said...
"Creator Brett Bailey has been fearlessly uncompromising in his approach. The experience in the exhibition hall is entirely without comfort. Confronting us with the appalling realities of Europe's colonial past – the stuff I definitely wasn't taught at school – isn't just some kind of guilt trip." (Five Stars)
The Guardian - read full review
"In Exhibit B, as in no other piece of art I have seen, we are part of the show, not only gazing but gazed at, measured and judged.
"The sense of sorrow and shame is overwhelming, along with a liberating sense that something that had to be said has been said, with a decisive and terrible eloquence." (Five Stars)
The Scotsman - read full review
"The stage and costume designs are impeccably detailed, and the whole exhibition is underpinned by a haunting choir singing live.
"It's traumatic. It's edifying. It's essential. Spare 20 minutes to witness 300 years of persecution." (Five Stars)
Edinburgh Festivals magazine - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Divallusion
YouTube sensation Christina Bianco and cabaret star Velma Celli present a selection of pop divas, including Barbara Streisand, Shakira, Celine Dion and more.
-
Watch Divallusion
The duo present a selection of pop divas in their own inimitable style, filmed at a Fringe preview show.

What the reviewers said...
"Christina Bianco makes her UK debut in her uniquely brilliant diva cabaret impression show, Divallusion. Teaming up with Velma Celli, the pair take us through a journey of diva songs and impressions that leave the audience in awe of the performances." (Five Stars)
What's On Stage - read full review
"A highlight was a memorable homage to Aussie star Sia's 'Chandelier' video (complete with glittering body stocking). The duo's onstage chemistry keeps the humour bouncing back and forth, and makes their obvious talent shine all the more brightly. Fabulous in every sense of the word." (Five Stars)
Three Weeks - read full review
"There is a vast range of stars that she has in her repertoire and it's a thrill to close your eyes and feel like we are sitting in a room listening to Judy Garland singing Somewhere over the Rainbow." (Four Stars)
Broadway Baby - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
The James Plays
One of the highlights from 2014's International Festival programme, this vividly-imagined trilogy brings to life three generations of Stewart kings who ruled Scotland in the tumultuous 15th century.
Billed as historical drama for a contemporary audience, this co-production by the National Theatre of Scotland, the EIF and the National Theatre of Great Britain features an ensemble cast including Sophie Gråbøl (in James III), of The Killing fame and Blythe Duff (in James I).
BBC Arts provided an in-depth taster to the plays with a scene and actor interview from each one, plus a special introduction from writer Rona Munro as well as photo galleries and guides to each play.
-
Explore The James Plays
Scenes, actor interviews, photo galleries and guides to each play. Plus a special introduction from writer Rona Munro.

What the reviewers said...
"Munro's script is the star. As well as illuminating Scotland's history of distancing itself from England while uniting with Scandinavia and France, these plays all capture something elusive about Scottishness: that potent mix of individual spirit, darkness, alcohol and loyalty that can seem so foreign to the rest of Britain. Often, the writing is just very funny." (Five Stars)
The Telegraph - read full review
"This narrative driven piece achieves what Munro set out to do by being utterly human while showing a world of cold plotting and bloody treason in the pursuit and the holding of power told in Scots voices of now." (Five Stars)
Edinburgh Guide - read full review
"The play races along, helped by an atmospheric staging in modern language, featuring a deeply symbolic, menacing, 25-foot high sword, plus audience on stage behind the actors." (James I, Five Stars)
British Theatre Guide - read full review
"Things are only kept afloat for two reasons. First, Queen Margaret played superbly by The Killing favourite Sophie Gråbøl is, like her two predecessors, the kind of power behind the throne that should be running the country. Secondly, Scotland appears to have been politically stable for at least a decade and a half, allowing the King to chase around after anything in a skirt (or even a kilt)." (James III, Four Stars)
British Theatre Guide - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Circa: Beyond
Internationally acclaimed ensemble Circa invite you to step Beyond... into a surreal, moving world of blindfolds, Rubik’s Cubes and rabbit heads.
Beyond is a beautiful, mysterious place where bestial comedy meets irreverent vaudeville, with a score of show tunes, electronica, rock ballads and performances from world-class circus performers.
-
Watch Circa
A taster of the show from internationally acclaimed ensemble Circa.

What the reviewers said...
"On the Chinese Pole, on the trapeze, and on each other, they demonstrate the same inch-perfect technique borne out of endless repetition and rehearsal – laced with a little unhinged madness." (Five Stars)
The Scotsman - read full review
"Beyond traces an intimate path between grace and baseness, offsetting sensual choreography – Billie Wilson-Coffey’s exquisite, vulnerable aerial silk solo – with a wild feeling of letting-go." (Five Stars)
The List - read full review
"It's comical and works a subtle narrative string throughout the entire piece: here they are, the performers, going beyond the human, beyond the animal, they're themselves, about as strange and superhuman as you can get." (Five Stars)
Broadway Baby - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Inala
The Edinburgh International Festival's flagship dance event was Inala, a fusion of South African dance and classical ballet combining the musical talents of four-time Grammy Award-winning choir Ladysmith Black Mambazo with stunning performances from the dancers of the Royal Ballet and Rambert.
-
Watch scenes from Inala
Two clips from this stunning fusion of South African dance and classical ballet, filmed at International Festival previews.

What the reviewers said...
"The choir are every bit as much a part of the action on stage as the dancers, performing their own routines, or parodying the ballet to extract a laugh from their rapt audience. The standing ovation said it all; a truly joyful and transporting experience." (Five Stars)
Edinburgh Festivals magazine - read full review
"The best of them feels exhilaratingly new-minted, in classically shaped jumps and turns that are earthed to a percussive African energy – fierce feral moves that are part human, part animal." (Four Stars)
The Guardian - read full review
"[Ladysmith Black Mambazo] are a constantly generous presence, and their 11th-hour line-up across the width of the entire stage – those voices soaring out as never before – is a thing of simple but stirring beauty." (Four Stars)
The Telegraph - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Frisky and Mannish
Following successful sold out shows in the West End and at the Sydney Opera House, musical comedy cabaret duo, Frisky and Mannish, returned to the Edinburgh Fringe this year in what they describe as a “barely-conscious recoupling”.
Felicity Fitz-Frisky (Laura Corcoran) and Hansel Amadeus Mannish (Matthew Floyd Jones) formed in March 2008. The pair have enjoyed several successful runs at the Edinburgh Fringe. Their loyal fan base love the duo’s blend of pitch perfect vocals, seething parody and pop music mash-ups.
This year's show, Just Too Much, lampoons familiar tabloid tales of celebrity excess and high profile hedonism.
-
The Wheels on the Bus
Watch the duo perform a classic track at this year's festival previews, which sees childhood nursery rhymes reworked to the tune of Girls Aloud’s The Sound of the Underground.

What the reviewers said...
"With fantastic musical references from Beiber to Bette Midler taking in all the very best - and very worst - of pop, musicals, pop culture and fashion there just aren’t enough superlatives to describe the experience of an hour with Frisky & Mannish." (Five Stars)
Broadway Baby - read full review
"There are of course their fantastic vocals, cunning mash-ups and over-the-top stage personalities but this time there is more. As the show is about excess, they indulge themselves and happily the audience goes along for the ride." (Five Stars)
British Theatre Guide - read full review
"The pair re-imagine letters from Sinéad O’Connor to a horde of pop stars, interrogate songs that could be considered feminist anthems, host a game of Know Your Lord(e)s, and generally try to pack in more chart references than a Radio 1 Sunday night slot." (Three Stars)
Fest magazine - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Forgotten Voices
Actors give voice to personal WW1 testimonies from the Imperial War Museum's archives, based on the book Forgotten Voices of the Great War by Max Arthur. Forgotten Voices was performed at the Pleasance Grand.
Regular cast changes accommodated guest performers over the Edinburgh run, including Robert Vaughn, Julian Sands, Peter Bowles, Chrisopher Timothy, Celia Imrie and Robert Powell.
-
Watch Forgotten Voices
Watch a preview clip of Forgotten Voices featuring guest star Robert Vaughn.

What the reviewers said...
"All of the actors play their roles convincingly – Julian Sands gives a very sensitive and convincing performance, and Robert Vaughn’s delightful appearance as ‘the Yank who saves the day’ reminds us of how many other nations bravely joined the war effort and the scale of their losses." (Five Stars)
Edinburgh Festivals magazine - read full review
"The testimonies are taken from a cross-section of military and civilian society, including privates and officers, an American soldier, and – perhaps most moving of all – one of the women whose lives were forever changed by the war." (Four Stars)
Edinburgh Spotlight - read full review
"The stories may not reveal anything you didn’t already know, but combined with Nick Bicât’s original score, moving WW1 songs and a changing backdrop of paintings of the trenches, they will still force a lump into your throat." (Three Stars)
The Stage - read full review
-
Five Star Reviews
Browse the five star-rated clips and performances collection
Edinburgh Festivals Collections
-
International Festival
From the James Plays to Exhibit B... all our coverage of the EIF 2014.
-
Five Star Reviews
Content and performances from the reviewers' top-rated shows at the 2014 Edinburgh Festivals.
-
Music
Selected highlights from top musical acts at the 2014 Edinburgh festivals.
-
Spoken Word
The best spoken word content from the 2014 Edinburgh Festivals.