A game of two cliches
Having just sat down and watched Match of the Day 2 from Sunday night again, a question occurs, which hopefully someone might be able to answer.
In his analysis of the Newcastle v Sunderland game, Alan Hansen described it as a match in which "no quarter was asked". Al actually didn't get as far as completing the familiar phrase, but it is so well known the shorthand version would do.
But do we really know what the phrase means? I don't. I know it is a phrase used to describe the kind of match in which two sides display even greater than usual commitment, but how did it end up meaning that? What is a quarter in this context?
A quarter of Midget Gems may be neither asked for nor given down at your local sweet shop, but how has this expression become associated with football , and does it apply to other sports where there are quarters? American Football, for example?
Are there other football-related phrases which seem meaningless on the face of it but which everybody understands to mean the same thing?
There is a great book called the Football Lexicon by Leigh and Woodhouse - but quarters, whether they are asked for or given or not, don't get a mention.
As a commentator, I find the language of football pretty interesting and consciously try not to resort to cliché, though sometimes "Oh, what a goal!" just comes out of your mouth before you have the chance to stop it! Actually, sometimes the goal is so good there is not much else to say about it.
One colleague of mine often uses the expression "if my memory serves me correct" when what he actually means is "if my eyesight has not let me down". The reality is that the fact, whatever it may be, is written in front of him in his notes.
One radio commentator frequently says "it goes a long way" when the ball flashes into the penalty area, which, I reckon, is a time-buying device. It gives him a split second to establish exactly who has done what in the subsequent melee.
I would be very interested to know if I use any similar verbal ticks without realising it. As for the old "no quarter asked or given" question, any explanations out there?
Page 1 of 3
Comment number 1.
At 11:45 6th Feb 2009, jonners6 wrote:Quarter is an old word for mercy (according to the Webster dictionary, "mercy granted to a surrendering foe." A defeated army might have to surrender, but they did not have to ask for or accept mercy ("cry for quarter"); it would have been a show of bravery and pride to accept whatever harsh treatment the enemy then meted out. This saying is found on very old military reports in reference to captured prisoners.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 11:46 6th Feb 2009, jonners6 wrote:So therefore in the footballing context it means that there was no mercy, shown or given, by either side
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 11:55 6th Feb 2009, RostokMcSpoons wrote:There's a good attempt at explaining it here:
https://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-giv1.htm
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
At 11:58 6th Feb 2009, cappers43 wrote:good explanation from post No.1,but i thought this was a well known phrase and not only used in a footballing context. I'm kind of suprised that you're not sure where it originates from
Complain about this comment (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
At 11:59 6th Feb 2009, StJameshPark wrote:How is "what a goal!" a cliche? To me that is just expressing an opinion.
Lines like Slide Rule Pass, Threaded Ball and Cross-Come-Shot are football cliches.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 5)
Comment number 6.
At 12:00 6th Feb 2009, MrBlueBurns wrote:I think alot of phrases that we understand as cliches have a services background or from Shakespeare and we just don't know it.
Brass monkey weather and a pound of flesh respectively, though I appreciate these aren't necessarily just restricted to sport.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 6)
Comment number 7.
At 12:05 6th Feb 2009, gandalf the white wrote:Yeah, as previous posters said it means mercy. Compare the folk song, High Barbaree:
Oh quarter oh quarter the pirates then did cry
Blow high blow low and so sailed we
No quarter will we give you but to sink you in the sea
A-sailing all along the coast of high barbaree
Which is pretty much the sentiment Alan Hansen was eruditely referrring to...
Complain about this comment (Comment number 7)
Comment number 8.
At 12:05 6th Feb 2009, babyfacedassasin2 wrote:There is a Led Zeppelin song called No Quarter. Something to do with mercy being shown/ not shown by armies years ago.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 8)
Comment number 9.
At 12:07 6th Feb 2009, umbongo82 wrote:Pretty shmabolic you did not know what that meant. It is not exactly a saying lost in the mists of time. C- must try harder.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 9)
Comment number 10.
At 12:10 6th Feb 2009, rastafairy wrote:What the &%$% does "a yard quicker " mean. It's one we hear often but it has no sense without context.
The most annoying is not exactly cliché but when commentators just recite what others say - "Drogba and Anelka / Gerrard and Lampard can't play together" being an obvious one.
And how many times this season have we heard "Arsenal are not playing their usual free flowing football". Maybe their free-flowing football is not so usual after all!
What about a relegation dogfight. Are there dogfighting leagues with promotions and relegations somewhere?
Still, it was a game of two halves, the boy done good and we are glad to come away with a point.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 10)
Comment number 11.
At 12:10 6th Feb 2009, Armchair Dave wrote:Before being sacked by ITV for "that incident", Ron Atkinson would regularly come out with baffling phrases to describe footballing action.
You can find them at https://www.ronglish.com/ website.
I don't know of any commentator or summarizer since that has used such bizarre phrases.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 11)
Comment number 12.
At 12:13 6th Feb 2009, Teiam - problem solved wrote:#9 Why are you marking his blog as though you're a teacher? I wouldn't be surprised if you're the same guy who marked Robbos blog, it's just pathetic, we're all human and just because one person knows something doesn't mean we all should do.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 12)
Comment number 13.
At 12:14 6th Feb 2009, oke2008 [RIP #15] wrote:in this current weather a few people might be saying brass monkey related cliques. this referes to the equipment used to hold canon balls on old ships and when it went below a certain temprature the canon balls would fall off, hence the expression "freeze the balls of a brass monkey"
back on topic i cant think of you over using any clique on MOTD and both my wife and i think you are the best comentator on the program along with Motty. keep up the good work
Complain about this comment (Comment number 13)
Comment number 14.
At 12:17 6th Feb 2009, PrestonSpur wrote:Do you get paid for writing this Steve..?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 14)
Comment number 15.
At 12:33 6th Feb 2009, Bury are Fantastic wrote:It always makes me chuckle when a commentator says, "The ball dipped at the last minute".
The last minute? What - in the two seconds between it leaving the player's boot and hitting the back of the net?
Football seems to have a language to itself, sometimes it doesn't make perfect sense but that's okay, we know what you're on about.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 15)
Comment number 16.
At 12:37 6th Feb 2009, serialcoins wrote:"If a Brazilian had done that, we'd all be raving about it."
Complain about this comment (Comment number 16)
Comment number 17.
At 12:39 6th Feb 2009, wrcarlson wrote:common phrase I notice is typically in reference to a shot going wide or a heavily weighted pass, "it was always going wide" or "he was never going to reach that." Being an american supporter at first I thought this was a funny unique way to say the shot is wide or the pass is too long but now it is just annoying.
https://www.futink.com
Complain about this comment (Comment number 17)
Comment number 18.
At 12:40 6th Feb 2009, Bury are Fantastic wrote:Yeah, in a field, somewhere in Hampshire.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 18)
Comment number 19.
At 12:40 6th Feb 2009, NeilH wrote:There is one phrase that makes me shout at the radio when football commentary is on.
Radio 5 Live commentators are always saying "[Insert team name here] are playing from left to right".
They're on the radio!!! Even if you do happen to know the ground, you don't know where the commentators are so it doesn't help.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 19)
Comment number 20.
At 12:45 6th Feb 2009, MrBlueBurns wrote:#11
I found Ron to be an entertaining commentator, certainly more so than Jim Beglin for example.
It's just a shame he was somewhat naive about the affect of his language, and remained so even after a visit to people who would be on the negative end of similar comments!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 20)
Comment number 21.
At 12:46 6th Feb 2009, AndySymes wrote:I've always what on eearth it means for a team to be "at sixes and sevens". I know it means they are all over the place but where does it come from?
From my knowledge, a six and a seven are right next to each when counting, not all over the place...
Complain about this comment (Comment number 21)
Comment number 22.
At 12:50 6th Feb 2009, superRoseyboy wrote:A couple of other cliches you only hear in relation to football.
"he can still do a job for us" which is usually used when an older play signs for a club towards the end of his career but frankly sounds like there are some low expectations
"we hope to get something ot of the game" which means we really hope we can scrape a draw!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 22)
Comment number 23.
At 12:52 6th Feb 2009, jamesg10 wrote:"Crucial first 20 minutes"
"The first goal will be crucial"
Switching sports;
"Crucial first 10 overs"
"Crucial last half hour of play"
and into politics;
"Crucial first 100 days" (Obama.)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 23)
Comment number 24.
At 12:54 6th Feb 2009, merryfred63 wrote:Am I alone in hating over-done commentary and then tiresome, repetitive 'analysis' ? Do we need several people to talk about a game we have seen with our own eyes ?
Doesn't the football or snooker speak for itself ? As for cliches and abuse of the English language by 'experts '....well...BBC, ITV and Sky could do worse than give commentators a refresher grammar course ( e.g. what is an adverb, an adjective etc. ).
Like many others, I record matches , ignore all of the yakkity-yak and watch only the football...with the sound turned down.
Finally, times are hard for ordinary folk and it is a slap in the face to see several blokes ( ok, I know about Gabby Logan ) being handsomely paid to merely talk about football. Get real .
Complain about this comment (Comment number 24)
Comment number 25.
At 12:55 6th Feb 2009, jamesg10 wrote:Winning manager's interview at full time;
"Alex, Arsene, Rafa, Martin, David......are you happy with the 3 points?"
They never say no..........
Complain about this comment (Comment number 25)
Comment number 26.
At 13:01 6th Feb 2009, pab1953 wrote:I think what is most disturbing about this post is that it's a perfect example of why people use cliches -- mainly because they're too lazy to find a better word or expression. In this case, Mr. Wilson asks us, his readers, to uncover the origin of "to give no quarter." Why doesn't he have interest in the language he uses to earn his living to Google the phrase, or -- perish the thought -- pick up a book and divine its meaning?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 26)
Comment number 27.
At 13:06 6th Feb 2009, BigShifty wrote:That ronglish website is freakin hilarious
""Tell You What"...Be warned that this landmark phrase can signal the beginning of an extended tirade of pure Ronglish."
Comedy gold
Complain about this comment (Comment number 27)
Comment number 28.
At 13:09 6th Feb 2009, therealmanbearpig wrote:And they asked No Quarter...
Led Zeppelin song, I assume it refers to 'mercy' as explained by post one.
Would fit with the lyrics of the song.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 28)
Comment number 29.
At 13:18 6th Feb 2009, Steve Wilson - Match of the Day wrote:Thanks for all your erudite replies! Perhaps as an English Language and Literature graduate I should have known that "quarter" meant "mercy" but, to may shame, I did not.
Thanks also for the explanation of brass monkey, excellent!
#13 oke2008 - appreciate your comment.
#14 prestonSpurs - no i do not, your licence fee is safe!
#19 neilh8 - as a former radio commentator I can tell you that if you did not say that you would be inundated with complaints! Some listeners evidently like to create a mental image of what they are hearing - it is all part of what Peter Jones the late great football commentator called "painting pcitures".
#21 AndySymes - "at sixes and sevens" - I refer to the Football Lexicon I mention above - this apparently relates to an expression used by City of London Livery Companies squabbling over their places in the Lord Mayor's parade.
#26 pab1953 - I posted the subject because I thought it might spark an intesting discussion beyond just banging on about who has signed who and so on.
In fact it has done exactly that, if you don't wish to take part then don't. I repeat that I am not paid for doing the blog, I do it because I enjoy it ---- most of the time.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 29)
Comment number 30.
At 13:21 6th Feb 2009, Steve Wilson - Match of the Day wrote:sorry about the typos above - reply in haste repent at leisure.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 30)
Comment number 31.
At 13:24 6th Feb 2009, CriostoirOg wrote:This is ever so slightly off topic, but you'll understand where I'm coming from, I hope:
In Ireland we have a commentator called Micheal O Muircheartaigh for Gaelic Games, who doesn't exactly resort to cliche's, but rather creates entire works of prose whilst delivering play by play commentary; a classic example being:
"Pat Fox has it on his hurl and is motoring well now ... but here comes Joe Rabbitte hot on his tail ...... I've seen it all now, a Rabbitte chasing a Fox around Croke Park!"
(more can be found on his wikipedia page)
The man is a national icon and rightly so, known as the Voice of Gaelic Games. Granted that the more local nature of Irish sport allows for a more intimate commentary, but still, wouldn't it be great if the Beeb could have their commentators go off into their own little world whilst keeping us all well informed on the action!?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 31)
Comment number 32.
At 13:25 6th Feb 2009, AndySymes wrote:Thanks for the "sixes and sevens" clarification, Steve. It's one that's always puzzled me and I've found many an explanation but they usually regard risk, not disorganisation.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 32)
Comment number 33.
At 13:39 6th Feb 2009, Steve wrote:"To be honest" - if they don't say that first are they lying ?
And why are defenders always described as "big" ? eg Big John Terry , Big Rio etc.
Another strange saying is "a must win game" - do you play some games you don't have to win ?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 33)
Comment number 34.
At 13:39 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:to #10 - relegation dogfight is another military reference. The airforce were involved in dogfights which are basically plane vs plane and all but every man for himself.
I must admit I like football language! Although it seems I may be a minority...
"Always going wide" is a good one, always puts me in mind of "couldn't hit a cow's rump with a banjo" for the more PC commentators...
Complain about this comment (Comment number 34)
Comment number 35.
At 13:41 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:"6 pointer" is always used too especially when relating to relegation (spot the Leeds fan! haha!) - the fact that you only get 3 points for winning doesn't seem to stop it being used end of every season over and over! And yes, I know its because you get 3 and it stops your rival getting 3, but meh
Complain about this comment (Comment number 35)
Comment number 36.
At 13:42 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:"it was going in as soon as it left his boot"
Like Mr Cech or Mr Friedel wouldn't have anything to say about it?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 36)
Comment number 37.
At 13:49 6th Feb 2009, dswing wrote:Why do all pundits use the term "for me"...?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 37)
Comment number 38.
At 13:49 6th Feb 2009, Beard_of_Shame wrote:The cliche that drives me to distraction is when a commentator says after a slightly unusual set-piece, "That's one from the training ground". Where the hell else do you think they practised it?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 38)
Comment number 39.
At 13:52 6th Feb 2009, dswing wrote:"Six of one, half a dozen of the other...."
"it was handbags..."
Complain about this comment (Comment number 39)
Comment number 40.
At 13:55 6th Feb 2009, MadMancHatter wrote:Im not so bothered about the use of cliches in football, its the awful puns that football journalists come up with that bug me.
One that always sticks in my head, after pennant had given liverpool the lead against chelsea a few years back the sky caption at half time said "Jermaine Man".
Complain about this comment (Comment number 40)
Comment number 41.
At 13:56 6th Feb 2009, royalnilcoitetprima wrote:My most annoying point is when 'keepers punch or palm a ball wide for a corner, or back out into play, and the commentator , obviously bereft of anything sensible to say, comes out with "What a great save!"
It is obvious to anyone with eyes in their head that the ball had NOT,in fact, been saved-ie the 'keeper had a hold of it.
Time after time, during the course of a game, commentators make the same, or similar comments, and I find it v annoying.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 41)
Comment number 42.
At 13:56 6th Feb 2009, timwebber wrote:The one I hate the most is "absolutely top drawer".
But maybe that's just because Andy Gray says it, and he's an idiot.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 42)
Comment number 43.
At 13:58 6th Feb 2009, timwebber wrote:Also, anything where the player is referred to as "son"...again this seems to be Gray's speciality.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 43)
Comment number 44.
At 13:58 6th Feb 2009, miggie_10 wrote:archie mcpherson
wwwwwoooooooooaaaaaafffffffffffff!!!!!!!!!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 44)
Comment number 45.
At 14:04 6th Feb 2009, sam400d wrote:What the hell is "the rub of the green" and a"stonewall " penalty, ?!?!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 45)
Comment number 46.
At 14:15 6th Feb 2009, socrates wrote:One of my favourites is when a pundit is talking about the league and refers to "the so-called big four".
Alan Brazil did so the other day on the radio, but got slightly mixed up, and said "the so-called top four".
Complain about this comment (Comment number 46)
Comment number 47.
At 14:18 6th Feb 2009, Gonzo wrote:I find the use of cliches far less annoying than pieces of writing like this where even some basic research would have answered any questions you might have had. The fact you're in a position to write for such a large audience and don't understand the meaning of words - that are not so archaic as you make them seem - is shocking.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 47)
Comment number 48.
At 14:18 6th Feb 2009, MrBlueBurns wrote:What about Jamie Redknapp and his over use of the word 'literally'.
I literally want to throttle him!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 48)
Comment number 49.
At 14:30 6th Feb 2009, Toonraider99 wrote:Do I really subsidise this site with my license fee to read nonsense like this? What on earth did you think quarter was? A measurement? Seriously, you need some further education.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 49)
Comment number 50.
At 14:36 6th Feb 2009, Zulu Warrior wrote:Steve
Its good to get a fresh set of vocals on the commentary.
Please avoid 'fresh legs' and any over analysis or meaningless stat like
'If my memory serve me right - thats the only the fourth time a one-eyed centre back with red hair has scored the winner in the FA cup semi final.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 50)
Comment number 51.
At 14:53 6th Feb 2009, jonners6 wrote:In response to post 21:
If someone is at sixes and sevens then they are in a quandary; they don't quite know what to do next. The saying originates from a situation in 1327 and relates to the Guilds of Tradesmen in the City of London. The Merchant Taylors and the Skinners were founded within a few days of each other, five other Guilds having already received their charters. The age of each Guild dictated its position in the Lord Mayor's procession. The Merchant Taylors and the Skinners argued for fifty years as to which should go sixth in the procession. In the end, in 1494, Sir Robert Billesden, the current Lord Mayor, decreed that they should take it in turns to go sixth and seventh.
An alternative explanation that the saying has something to do with throwing dice is much less likely, and far less romantic.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 51)
Comment number 52.
At 14:55 6th Feb 2009, dan_saintsfc_om wrote:good blog steve, and yes it has sparked off decent debate. its just a shame there are some out there who are overly critical.
on the cliche front, you often hear that the defending team must 'win the second ball'. Its quality that we can all nod our heads in agreement upon hearing these phrases however!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 52)
Comment number 53.
At 14:58 6th Feb 2009, dhenry wrote:I get tired of hearing the inanae chatter from the likes of John Motson and David Pleat who not only bore us to tears with drivel but constantly use the term ebb and flow
Complain about this comment (Comment number 53)
Comment number 54.
At 15:03 6th Feb 2009, bertrandmcnally wrote:#19, seriously? It doesn't matter where in the stand the commentators are, they are letting you know how the action will be relayed from their perspective.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 54)
Comment number 55.
At 15:03 6th Feb 2009, timwebber wrote:Funniest bit of commentary by Motson, a couple of years ago during a particularly boring England friendly as I recall....
"Eriksson adjusting his glasses there....[long pause]....his spectacles".
Complain about this comment (Comment number 55)
Comment number 56.
At 15:03 6th Feb 2009, Foot245 wrote:The cliche that all commentators seem to use is that of describing tackles as 'challenges'.
When did a tackle become a 'challenge'? The word tackle is in the Laws of the Game. So why not use it?
Is it the fad with using 'nice sounding' words to describe things? Like passed away for died.
If it is a tackle call it that. Two players jumping to head the ball - fair enough to call that a challenge if you wish.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 56)
Comment number 57.
At 15:08 6th Feb 2009, oke2008 [RIP #15] wrote:thanks you bringing to mind Andy Gray. the one thing that ruins FIFA '09 "open your top draw and pop that one in"!!!! WHAT
all said and done (pun intended) John Madden of NFL fame is the worst for cliques
Complain about this comment (Comment number 57)
Comment number 58.
At 15:11 6th Feb 2009, WesGleeson wrote:The 'corridor of uncertainty' and/or the 'mixer' are two particular favourites of mine, even though the former was stolen from cricket
Complain about this comment (Comment number 58)
Comment number 59.
At 15:12 6th Feb 2009, greysweetalkinguy wrote:#21
The phrase apparently refers to civic parades in the old days. Everybody had to line up in order of seniority. When two people dis agreed about the order and resorted to squabbling, this was referred to "being at sixes and sevens".
Also, in the days of Robin Hood, when chaps would fight with quarter-staffs. Holding a quarter-staff meant one hand at the mid-point and the other between there and the end. A quarter-staff is a pole rather like a Boy Scout's staff. There is not a lot you can do with two hands, but it can become more effective one-handed, ie no quarter.
In games played where the slope of the pitch can have an effect, they toss for ends and play a half each way. Therefore "a level playing-field" is a meaningless cliche.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 59)
Comment number 60.
At 15:21 6th Feb 2009, LawBestCharlton wrote:# 33: I have NEVER heard Rio Ferdinand referred to as "Big Rio"!
I am assuming #49 is on a wind-up. If not, I really pity you...
#45: The 'stonewall' penalty - absolutely annoys me too, especially the various versions of it - stonecold penalty, stonewall penalty....
One that I havent heard for a while - educated foot - as in "that lad, he's spraying the ball around the park with his educated left foot"
Personally, I love football cliches! It's quite funny the way pundits and commentators can completely murder the English language to describe a game of football...
Great article!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 60)
Comment number 61.
At 15:26 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:Rub of the green puts me in mind of lawn bowls where the way the grass is lying will affect the way your ball rolls... snooker too with the baize!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 61)
Comment number 62.
At 15:31 6th Feb 2009, juninhowept wrote:you're a football writer! how can you not know what quarter means? i thought shakespeare got forced down everyone's throats... obviously not. and 'if my memory serves me correctly" means 'my eyes are working'? HOW??? it means if i remember correctly, not 'i think i just saw that' - so is he wrong, or you? why have you just written a blog to tell us you can't write? SORT IT OUT
Complain about this comment (Comment number 62)
Comment number 63.
At 15:40 6th Feb 2009, BLuesBJ wrote:A cliche I can't stand is "two minuties of time" - as if there were two minutes of place, two minutes of dimension, etc and it needed to be qualified by saying two minuties of time. Just two minutes will do, especially as a journalist you need to speak in soundbites, more so towards the end of the match.
Also, sometimes commentators shift allegiances so quickly - a dominant team might have had 10 attempts and plenty of posession, and the other team one shot from which they socre, and yet as soon as they score, the commentator claims it was always clear who would score first, and how the team with one chance deserved something out of the game!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 63)
Comment number 64.
At 15:48 6th Feb 2009, bpwmanu wrote:"He finished that with great aplomb" - now forgive me for questioning the intellect of the regular commentator here, but if you can find one commentator who actually knows what 'aplomb' means, i'll ... well, I'll, just.
However, if you want to hear real 'guff' commentating, there is nobody to surpass good old Sid Wadell on the darts - he needs to see a Harley street specialist the amount of utter bilge that comes out of him
Complain about this comment (Comment number 64)
Comment number 65.
At 15:51 6th Feb 2009, claretmad1882 wrote:Jim Beglin always annoys me with his cliches. His favourites are
"that was meat and drink for the goalkeeper"
and whenever a player heads the ball down, and it bounces over the bar
"well as a young lad your always told to head the ball down"
Complain about this comment (Comment number 65)
Comment number 66.
At 15:51 6th Feb 2009, chips_in_the_queue wrote:"He headed it too well"
When someone gets too much on his header and heads it wide.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 66)
Comment number 67.
At 15:51 6th Feb 2009, donwendy wrote:Five minutes on Google would ahve found you the answers to your questions. I believe the technique is called research, you and your colleagues might like to try it some time as the inane and inaccurate nonsense that you lot spew forth every weekend is so tiresome that I watch with the sound off.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 67)
Comment number 68.
At 16:02 6th Feb 2009, NottinghamHotspur wrote:people on this discussion need to stop calling them 'cliques'.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 68)
Comment number 69.
At 16:04 6th Feb 2009, Leviticus wrote:I was watching a match on the internet the other night with just the commentator. It seemed very strange, almost eerie. I concluded that I preferred the now standard arrangement of a commentator plus an analyst. Dependent on the quality of both however.
My preferred analyst is David Pleat. I consider him to be to be concise and informative and essentially honest and impartial. Sadly however too many of the commentators like the sound of their own voice and rather stick to the commentary of the match want to impress with a raft of superflous and unnecessary chat, information and statistics. Basically BORING.
Worst offenders being, er, all of them. One of the worst was ( much improved ) Clive Tyldesley. He used to think of himself as a bit of a Jack Dee stand up at one time I think. Always the droll, as he thought, comment. Just the commentary Clive, forget the jokes.
But cliches? Football is full of them.
Every game is now MASSIVE. And - ' he will be disappointed with that '. Meaning, ' what a plonker - how on earth did a highly paid pro miss a sitter like that ?'
The least said about the BBC pundits the better. More like the ' old boys' club.
But not confined to football, my most irritating cliche is ' in the mix '.
And delusional managers.' We would have won 3-0, (after losing 5-0 ) if we had defended better '. Really? So whose fault is that then? And ' We are looking for a result'. I though every game ended in a result? And solid defending has now become 'parking the bus in front of goal'.
But then those in and connected with football have never exactly been University graduates in English grammar have they?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 69)
Comment number 70.
At 16:14 6th Feb 2009, smashingredXI wrote:@ 37.
I blame David Beckham for the rise and rise of 'for me'. I'm sure it was hardly ever heard until he went to Real Madrid. Spanish people say 'para mi' a lot and this translation seems to have crept in to beckham's lexicon and now everyone else in football.
For me, lawro is the werst offender (by the way).
Complain about this comment (Comment number 70)
Comment number 71.
At 16:14 6th Feb 2009, spursfortheleague wrote:Yes Steve how DARE you spark conversation on a blog by asking questions instead of just looking them up?
It seems quite simple to me - if you don't like the topic stop wasting your time reading and then replying to it. Go and make youself feel superior somewhere else.
Personally I think David Pleat has a tendancy to talk complete rubbish (no offence intended) or to state the bleeding obvious.
I love most cliches (game of two halves etc), having its own language makes football unique and I think is part of the reason many people love it.
I also would love to know where 'stonewall penalty comes from though. Any ideas anyone?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 71)
Comment number 72.
At 16:15 6th Feb 2009, jay842 wrote:skilful black players are always termed 'unpredictable', but surely if their always unpredictable doesn't that make them predictable?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 72)
Comment number 73.
At 16:16 6th Feb 2009, Leviticus wrote:Good commentator? Barry Davies.
Worst cliche. ' At this moment in time'. You mean this moment can occur outside of time and/or a moment isn't connected with time?
What is meant of course is, ' at this moment ' or ' at this time '.
Perhaps a very bad cliche should be described as a Kinnearism?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 73)
Comment number 74.
At 16:20 6th Feb 2009, RetiredNo6 wrote:Some of the criticisms on here are incredible.
Of course Steve could have researched it if he wanted to, but he was posting it as a topic for people to discuss and debate. Some of the patronising responses will probably make him think twice about doing that in the future.
Give the commentators a break. We all have our favourites and ones that we don't like. But believe me as somebody who did a little bit of radio commentary a few years ago - it is very difficult. It's not always possible to analyse and prepare everything perfectly, you just have to react to what goes on in the game. You have a split second to come up with an explanation.
I personally think the standard on the BBC is pretty good, some of the Five Live guys are especially excellent.
And I generally enjoy Steve's blogs. But if I don't I just move on. I don't here and pretend to be some great scholar and criticise him.
Some people just love to moan.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 74)
Comment number 75.
At 16:22 6th Feb 2009, it's me wrote:I can't understand why there are so many people complaining about this blog and the apparent lack of commentators education.
How boring would this blog have been if Steve Wilson simply put; "I always wondered what 'no quarter asked or given meant', but I went on Google and found out and now I know."
I can also pretty much guarantee that there are phrases and words in usage that people will not have heard before, and as such not know the definition.
Personally I thought this was an interesting blog, and I've learnt some things from it and also re-affirmed knowledge
Complain about this comment (Comment number 75)
Comment number 76.
At 16:43 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:I think #67 might be off his meds, sorry Steve on his behalf!
Sparking a debate and asking questions to give your readership a chance to show their own knowledge is a million times better than google-ing the answer so leave the stroppy lad to spit his dummy. Probably bored at home unable to get to school due to the snow so has no other children to validate his existance by laughing at his disruptive influence.
Phew, that took some typing! *gets down off soapbox*
Either way, top one Steve. Nothing wrong with giving some of us who have loads of useless facts and knowledge to share a chance to share them!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 76)
Comment number 77.
At 16:44 6th Feb 2009, Hughesie wrote:Nice article Steve - refreshing and different and debate-stimulating - all articles should be!
I always love the descriptions of turf-skimmers/daisey cutter balls - Sean Lock did an excellent piece on other terms that could be used such as 'worm murder/groundy-rolly-goal/molescuffer'! Although you don't tend to hear them that often recently.
Another one for me is 'the shot cannons back of the WOODWORK'? Please clarify for me, as I may be just a little wanting for knowledge in this relatively niche area but, are the goals actually made of wood (still)? Surely not with the amount of relative flexibility in the crossbar from a thumping drive; 'the crossbar is still shaking from that effort'? Presumed they were reinforced plastic/metal composite? (Somewhat piccy, but it's something that I'm wondering about now).
One that I don't really like, but is massively subjective dependent upon your taste preference is; 'that's an absolute PEACH of a goal.' Peaches are okay, don't get me wrong - but they're probably not most peoples favourites? Maybe they are - I dunno! :)
Also, references to 'SWEEPING balls' - are we watching Fantasia here? Not sure the balls actually clean/collect/clear anything along their route. :)
On the whole though, I like the cliches. As long as they are not too overly used - I agree cetain commentators stick to them more than others and it can be frustrating - but on the whole it gives the game and the commentary a certain level of character that would be a shame to miss out on. Particularly in the age where comparatively prohibitive television rights for 3:00pm games means so many people rely on radio commentary, such occasional use of cliches can bring an otherwise drab game to life or make you wonder how eccentric/random can one commentator be (ahem - Stuart Hall - so unique!).
Before I cease the tangential raving...can anyone tell me where 'Derby' comes from - as in, 'the North London Derby' this weekend? Obviously I am aware of the horse race (its only 2 miles from me) but looking at dictionary definitions they seem to link either to that horse race OR to a felt, stiff brimmed hat?! Unless this was something to do with the period of the origin of the word to mean a game where lots of people would turn out (and the average person would therefore wear a ''derby'? Can anyone help here?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 77)
Comment number 78.
At 16:46 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:Commentary wise we have a big disagreement in my house every time the snooker is on... I quite enjoy the musings of Virgo, Taylor, Thorne and Griffiths but the wife hates them. In particular she thinks John Virgo never talks anything but total poop-deck (the way we swear around our young daughter!)
Just the way it is I guess, some people think it enhances a game having an insight and observations from respected former pro's, some people should just mute the TV or give me back the remote and go make my coffee! Who's with me? hahaha
Complain about this comment (Comment number 78)
Comment number 79.
At 16:52 6th Feb 2009, God_Tony_Yeboah_21 wrote:#77 - some excellent ones in there! Woodwork is from the fact that goals used to made of wood I would guess, but then you had probably guessed that yourself. But sweeping ball is grand and PEACH is fantastic! Anyone any idea's on that one? Also pearler is used (although a lot more at parks level where I am) and I don't have a jar'o'glue about that one either!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 79)
Comment number 80.
At 16:54 6th Feb 2009, wotsthenews wrote:Nice one Steve; light the touch-paper and stand well back
Complain about this comment (Comment number 80)
Comment number 81.
At 16:55 6th Feb 2009, Hughesie wrote:#80
Cheers - the whole 'blue touch paper' thing was the other I was going to mention but forgot!
What is that all about? Think I heard an explanation way back don't remember it - although I'm sure if someone comes up with the same explanation I'd remember it!
***
#79
Cheers too! :)
:)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 81)
Comment number 82.
At 16:57 6th Feb 2009, Daniel Craig David James wrote:Headed goals always seem to fall into two categories: bullet or glancing. I used to hate this, but I find a bizarre pleasure in hearing the phrases trotted out.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 82)
Comment number 83.
At 17:10 6th Feb 2009, PaulChasetownFC wrote:RE: #77
Quite a few old footballing expressions have held out since the early days.
I still hear and read reporters who use the expression "turned on a sixpence", and, of course, since we went metric, should we really be referring to the game as having a six-yard box etc etc.
Just to digress slightly from English expressions that have gone on to become football expressions, are there many that BEGAN in football and are now used in every day life? I understand "Back to Square One" stems from football radio commentary.
To end, I dabbled with radio journalism twice in the Chasetown FA Cup run of 2005. I was reporting for Radio WM for the Chasetown v Blyth Spartans replay and I was so excited at Chasetown's winner through Karl Edwards that I said, "The cross came from the left wing, I have no idea who from, and, frankly, I don't care!" :)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 83)
Comment number 84.
At 17:11 6th Feb 2009, SummersIron wrote:72. At 4:15pm on 06 Feb 2009, jay842 wrote:
skilful black players are always termed 'unpredictable', but surely if their always unpredictable doesn't that make them predictable?
__________________________
Can we then agree (or agree to disagree) that these skilful black players you speak of are 'predictably unpredictable'?
I actually hadn't noticed that they are 'always' given this description, but I daresay you're right about this.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 84)
Comment number 85.
At 17:11 6th Feb 2009, juninhowept wrote:"Nice one Steve; light the touch-paper and stand well back"
OR, expose your ignorance asking a question an english lit graduate should be able to answer in his sleep...
this is ridiculous! one of the staple phrases of football commentary, and the guy has no idea what it means - and devotes a whole column to asking it...
that said - these phrases are to the enrichment of all commentary. they turn it from a description into a language far more potent and descriptive than if would be otherwise. 'breaks/rides the tackle' is a lovely phrase. as is 'goalmouth scramble' - alliterative and conjures up the image perfectly.
for all that, the commentators need to have a grasp and understanding of the language they speak.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 85)
Comment number 86.
At 17:14 6th Feb 2009, Pritesh Rathod wrote:Re: #24 - you are not alone. If you watch some of the older sports TV coverage, you'll notice that the commentators said a lot less back then than they do now because the action spoke for itself. I think Richie Benaud said that this was one of his golden rules - sometimes less is more. I wish that more TV commentators these days followed that advice.
As for #78, I agree with your wife about John Virgo!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 86)
Comment number 87.
At 17:16 6th Feb 2009, Eyetoldyouso wrote:Not really a cliche but the use of the superlative when there are only two teams playing I find incredibly irritating.
This is not confined to football commentators, you are likely to hear it in almost all sports.
Are they simply ignorant or just lazy?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 87)
Comment number 88.
At 17:22 6th Feb 2009, bpwmanu wrote:'Slide rule pass' - now don't get me wrong, but when was the last time you saw one of them?, and the footballers of today are surely too young to have ever seen one. Should update it to a "Casio N50 calculator function 15 pass"
"He cut through the defence like a knife through butter" - now pardon me, but I keep my butter in the fridge and there ain't nothing that the commentator says that could be more wrong than that one.
and what about, 'turn on a sixpence' - turn on the light or the kettle yes, but a sixpence !!!
Maybe I have some kind of Sid Wadell fixation, but commentaries would be a lot more colourful if they brought the language back down to earth where the regular fans reside. Forget the cliches and start using the language of the pub vault, where a lot of the fans would watch the match on TV.
"Tevez again, running around like a blue armed fly" - talking of which, does anybody know where that came from?
I can't really beech though because I have been watching the football for the last 12 or so years in Thailand, so I have been spared the likes of Andy Gray thankfully.
Personally think we should try to come up with an original saying of our own for Steve to use on all of his commentaries and see if it gets adopted into the mainstream - anybody have any starters for ten?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 88)
Comment number 89.
At 17:36 6th Feb 2009, spurgle5 wrote:Where on earth does "early doors" come from? I believe it was Ron Atkinson who introduced it and others now use it but what does it mean?
I also wonder why managers don't take a look at the fixture list and, if they're scheduled to play one of the"big 4", ask the FA to change the fixture to another day. How many times have you heard a manager, or player, say after a game, "on another day we would have won that game".
Hansen, Lawrenson and particularly Shearer have all "seen them given" when asked about contentious decisions. These guys are paid, quite hansomely i'm sure, to give their opinions and yet they come up with that!
Martin Tyler's insistence on shouting the surname of any player who has an attempt at goal. Andy Gray constantly reminding us, "i have to say", David Pleats attempts at pronouncing names such as "Shimbomba".
In spite of all of the above, i keep coming back for more.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 89)
Comment number 90.
At 17:44 6th Feb 2009, Leviticus wrote:The most ingratiating and almost obsequious cringe making commentaries and interviews I find however is in athletics and tennis. ( Sue Barker ) The exceptions being the terrific Michael Johnson and Mc Enroe. Especially with the the long distance runners and especially Paula Ratcliffe. Some of the unimaginative and repetitive questions and comments begger belief.
But remember the great 'Coleman balls '.
Such as I remember, when an athlete at an Olympics made a break down the back straight for the finish, DC said , ' there's no turning back now'.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 90)
Comment number 91.
At 17:45 6th Feb 2009, oke2008 [RIP #15] wrote:how about every player who scores the adjective has the same letter i.e. Rooney rams it in or Lampard lumps it in to the goal or again Berbatov bungs it home. it would make me laugh
Complain about this comment (Comment number 91)
Comment number 92.
At 17:57 6th Feb 2009, Leviticus wrote:bpwmanu wrote:
"Tevez again, running around like a blue armed fly"
It's a blue arsed fly. And as anyone familiar with flies knows. that's what they have. Except the green ones of course.
'turn on a sixpence' , means to turn in a small circumference not on or off.
And of course as anyone familiar with the catering profession knows butter kept in the fridge is more easily cut with a Knife. Even a blunt one.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 92)
Comment number 93.
At 18:02 6th Feb 2009, spicerthecoalman wrote:"Riding their luck" always sounds like a strange get-out phrase. Visions of horses being geed up in the final furlongs of the grand national don't really go with footy. When used in an unrelenting goal-mouth bombardment, you can excuse the poor commentator, who is reaching for any old words while inwardly sure that a goal is bound to happen any minute. But when used by a summariser? No excuse. You've had time to think about it.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 93)
Comment number 94.
At 18:17 6th Feb 2009, collie21 wrote:The ones that kills me, they make the pitch bigger, or the pitch is very big. I thought the pitch was a standard legal size so I just get confused when I hear both of these.
Incidently since the article was written Ronglish site can't be accessed, not enough band width ( of pitch), apparently his football park is smaller than all the others. Oh and number 93? better your luck than your missus.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 94)
Comment number 95.
At 18:18 6th Feb 2009, Leviticus wrote:Don't let us let the print journos escape cliche criticism.
Football managers must have become birds at times when they 'swoop' for a player they have bought. Do they perch on the stand roof I wonder?
And angry managers/players never seem to reply to criticism, they 'hit back' or ' roar '.
And I wonder if a player ever gets blistered feet after he has worked his socks off?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 95)
Comment number 96.
At 18:42 6th Feb 2009, heapy1986 wrote:Re 71
Hear, Hear,
football language while lacking grammatical prowess is nonetheless hugely entertaining; i for one would like to have Chris Kamara narrating my daily life: 'Oh...hes done it! !Unbelievable scenes! hes managed to get the bus to work!! And the Driver has change!!! back to you...'
(Off topic but....Hear Hear? Explanation anybody?)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 96)
Comment number 97.
At 18:49 6th Feb 2009, pigeon_saint wrote:Some people really need to get out more!!
Isn't this supposed to be a forum for discussing the beautiful game, not moaning like a bunch of....
I personally love watching the game with the sound on, can't think why anyone would want to watch a silent match...
In reference to the Gaelic Games commentator - I remember a commentator from quite a few years back describing a Ryan Giggs run and cross for Mark Hughes to score from as "Like a mini trying to catch a Porsche...and there's the Rolls Royce waiting in the middle!"
Mark Hughes a Rolls Royce? A damn fine striker, but never as beautiful as a Roller!!
Recently there's been a mass influx of articles/reporters using "Wotte" to replace "what a..." Highly original!! Now if only they were refering to a win.......
Complain about this comment (Comment number 97)
Comment number 98.
At 19:32 6th Feb 2009, jay_bee25 wrote:I've skipped a few posts between #70 and the 90s so forgive me if I cover anything that has already been said!
I've noticed that commentators/pundits/analysts are increasingly using the words 'absolute' or 'absolutely' to start off a sentence which grammatically doesn't require the need for the said words. Just watch Soccer Saturday every week and count how many times they say it.... it has always amused me.
Another thing from SS.... Jeff Stelling's use of the word 'squeak' for example "...and now to the game at Ewood. Do Blackburn have a squeak of a chance of getting something in the dying minutes?" Where did this come from!
Also I heard in one game when Don Goodman was co-commentator... "...and they owe him a grat of debtitude for saving them." lol!
Stonewall has only really crept in over the last 10 years or so I seem to remember.... I guess it means that a stonewall is perceived to be a sure fire thing, i.e. set in stone, meaning the penalty was certain and fully justified.... a stonewaller. I also remember Alan Hansen calling an FA Cup tie a few years back as a potential 'potato skin' for one of the bigger sides.... Lineker pulled him up on it straight away saying he'd only ever heard it being called a 'banana skin'!
I agree Clive Tyledsley is the most annoying commentator.... his jokes are never funny and he says THE most obvious things that don't need to be pointed out.
Motty is a legend in his own way..... it amuses me the way he says 'Drogbarrr'.
Martin Tyler and Peter Brackley are the best commentators imo.... Peter Brackley always reminds me of Serie A, he would be good on the BBC.
Andy Gray comes out with some stuff too.... "Sen....sational!" ...and from the 2000 FA Cup semi final between Chelsea and Newcastle when Rob Lee crosses for their equaliser "...and Rob Lee, not even given a numbahh!" ...always makes me laugh because he says it in reference to Lee's omission from Gullit's squad listings at the beginning of that season.
A cliche Alan Shearer has used a number of times is "If you don't buy a ticket, you won't win the raffle."
Lawro has used '..absolutely no hope for them" a few times.... whenever me or my brother say this in a normal conversation we say it in Lawro's accent!
The other one is Andy Townsend saying 'Time and time again" at least once or twice in each programme he does!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 98)
Comment number 99.
At 19:45 6th Feb 2009, redandblackT-Save 606 wrote:Comfortable on the ball
2 banks of four
Straight out of the top drawer
put in a good shift
worked his socks off
That'll hurt in the morning
heading toward row Z
Complain about this comment (Comment number 99)
Comment number 100.
At 20:08 6th Feb 2009, redandblackT-Save 606 wrote:ESPN's Derek Rae always enjoys calling out first,middle and last names after a spectacular play e.g Ivan Ramiro Cordoba.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 100)
Page 1 of 3